Why Most Emotional Intelligence Training Is Absolute Garbage (And What Actually Works)

Further Reading:

• Business Supervising Skills
• Professional Development Resources

Look, I'm going to start this with something that'll probably piss off half the HR managers reading this: 87% of emotional intelligence workshops are complete bollocks.

After 18 years running leadership programs across Australia—from Perth mining companies to Melbourne tech startups—I've watched countless managers walk out of EQ sessions more confused than when they walked in. They've got their workbooks full of notes about "empathetic listening" and "self-awareness matrices," but they still can't handle Dave from accounting having a meltdown about the coffee machine being broken.

The problem isn't that emotional intelligence doesn't matter. It bloody well does. The problem is how we're teaching it.

The Old Way Is Broken

Traditional emotional intelligence training treats emotions like spreadsheet data. Categorise them. Label them. File them away neatly. But here's the thing—emotions aren't quarterly reports. They're messy, contradictory, and they show up at the worst possible moments.

I remember sitting through a session where the facilitator spent 40 minutes explaining Goleman's four domains. Brilliant academic stuff. Then someone's phone rang with news their dad was in hospital, and the whole room fell apart. Theory met reality, and theory lost.

What Actually Works: The Melbourne Test

Three years ago, I started using what I call the Melbourne Test with my clients. It's simple but brutal.

I give managers real scenarios from their own workplace. Not generic case studies about "Sarah from Marketing" but actual situations they're dealing with right now. The warehouse supervisor who's been drinking. The team lead who micromanages because her own boss is breathing down her neck. The star performer who's become a toxic nightmare since their divorce.

The results? Night and day.

Instead of learning about emotional intelligence, they start practising it. They make mistakes. They get uncomfortable. They discover that managing difficult conversations isn't about following a script—it's about showing up as a human being who happens to be in charge.

The Three Things That Matter More Than Your EQ Score

Here's what 18 years has taught me about emotional intelligence in Australian workplaces:

1. Context beats theory every single time. Your empathy skills mean nothing if you can't read the room during a restructure. I've seen leaders with impressive EQ assessments completely miss that their team was terrified of losing their jobs while the leader was trying to "build engagement."

2. Consistency trumps perfection. The best managers I know aren't emotionally perfect. They're predictable. Their teams know what to expect from them on both good days and shit ones. This matters more than any emotional vocabulary they might have picked up in training.

3. Recovery skills matter more than prevention. You're going to screw up. You'll lose your temper, misread a situation, or completely miss that someone's struggling. The magic happens in what you do next, not in never making mistakes.

The Brisbane Incident (And Why It Changed Everything)

Two years back, I was running a program for a logistics company in Brisbane. Day one was going perfectly—everyone was engaged, taking notes, nodding at all the right moments. Then their biggest client called and cancelled a major contract.

The room went from collaborative to catastrophic in about thirty seconds. Instead of continuing with the planned curriculum, I scrapped everything and said, "Right, this is emotional intelligence training. What are we going to do?"

We spent the next four hours working through the real crisis. Not role-playing. Not hypotheticals. The actual disaster happening in their business right now.

That's when it clicked for me. Emotional intelligence isn't something you learn and then apply. It's something you develop through dealing with real stuff when it actually matters.

Stop Measuring, Start Practising

Companies love EQ assessments because they give nice, neat scores. But emotional intelligence isn't a test you pass—it's a muscle you build.

The organisations doing this well aren't running quarterly EQ workshops. They're creating environments where people can practice being human while getting work done. They're having regular one-on-ones that aren't just task reviews. They're acknowledging that business is personal, especially when you're asking people to spend 40 hours a week together.

What This Means for Your Team

If you're serious about developing emotional intelligence in your workplace, stop buying programs that promise to "assess and improve your team's EQ scores." Start with this instead:

Create space for real conversations about real problems. When someone's struggling, don't immediately jump to solutions. When there's conflict, don't avoid it until it explodes. When you stuff up as a leader, own it properly.

And for the love of all that's holy, stop pretending that emotional intelligence is some mystical leadership superpower. It's not. It's just being decent to the people you work with, paying attention to what's actually happening around you, and responding like a human being instead of a management textbook.

The Uncomfortable Truth

Here's what most leadership training won't tell you: emotional intelligence matters most when everything's going to hell. When the numbers are good and morale is high, anyone can look emotionally intelligent. The test comes when redundancies are looming, when clients are angry, when deadlines are impossible, and when good people are considering walking out the door.

That's when your real EQ shows up. Not in how well you can identify emotions on a worksheet, but in whether you can keep your team together when it counts.

And if your current emotional intelligence training can't handle that reality, it's time to find something that can.

The Bottom Line

Emotional intelligence isn't about being nice. It's about being effective with people when it actually matters. Stop treating it like a soft skill that's nice to have, and start treating it like the core business competency it actually is.

Your teams will thank you for it. Eventually.